Christmas Leftovers Toastie
We may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. How this works.
A Christmas leftovers toastie with turkey, stuffing and cranberry needs two things: thin, evenly spread layers so the cold centre heats right through, and cranberry sauce kept in the middle where it can't burn on the plates. Take the leftovers out of the fridge 10 minutes early, build it in the order below and give it about 5 minutes in a standard toastie maker.
On this page
Recipe: Christmas leftovers toastie
Ingredients
- 2 slices medium white bread
- 50g cooked turkey, thinly sliced or shredded
- 30g cooked stuffing, crumbled
- 1 tbsp cranberry sauce
- 30g mature cheddar or Wensleydale, grated
- 1 tsp gravy (thick, cold) or mayonnaise
- A few leaves of cooked sprout, finely shredded (optional)
- 10g softened butter for the outside
Method
- Take the turkey and stuffing out of the fridge 10 minutes before you start. Preheat the toastie maker with the lid closed.
- Shred the turkey into small pieces and crumble the stuffing so there are no lumps thicker than about 1cm.
- Butter one side of each slice. Place one slice butter-side down on the bottom plate and scatter half the cheese over it, leaving a 1cm border.
- Spread the gravy or mayo thinly over the cheese, then add the turkey, the stuffing and the sprouts in flat, even layers.
- Spoon the cranberry sauce into the very centre in a small blob rather than spreading it to the edges. Cover with the remaining cheese.
- Top with the second slice, butter-side up, and close the lid gently. If the latch won't close without force, take some filling out.
- Cook for 4½–5 minutes until deep golden. Rest for 1 minute, then cut. The centre should be steaming hot.
Why layering matters with cold leftovers
A normal cheese toastie starts at room temperature in the middle. Leftovers come out of a fridge at around 5°C, and a sealed toastie maker heats mostly through the bread. Thick chunks of turkey or a wedge of stuffing can still be cool at the core when the outside is perfectly browned.
Shredding the meat, crumbling the stuffing and letting both sit out for 10 minutes means there is less distance for the heat to travel. The cheese on both sides acts as glue and as a moisture barrier, and a thin smear of gravy or mayo stops the turkey tasting dry. Leftover cooked meat should be reheated until it is steaming hot all the way through, and only reheated once.
Cranberry sauce is mostly sugar. If it reaches the crimped edge it caramelises and then scorches onto the plates, which is one of the most common reasons festive toasties stick. A centred spoonful gives you a pocket of sharp sweetness in every half without the clean-up. Our guide on why toasties stick covers getting burnt sugar off.
Machine notes: deep fill is worth it here
Leftovers are bulky, and this is the recipe where a deep fill toastie maker earns its cupboard space. With extra-deep plates you can use 80g turkey, 50g stuffing and 45g cheese; cook for 5½–6 minutes. If you don't own one yet, a deep fill model like the Breville Deep Fill Sandwich Toaster is a common choice for exactly this sort of filling. Check price on Amazon
On a panini press, use thicker bread or a split bloomer and allow 5–6 minutes; the filling won't be sealed in, so keep the cranberry central. In a pan, cover with a lid for the first 2 minutes to push heat into the middle (see the frying pan toastie method). In the air fryer, 170°C for 10 minutes, turning halfway.
Variations
- Pigs in blankets: slice 2 cooked pigs in blankets lengthways and lay them flat in place of the stuffing.
- Ham and mustard: leftover glazed ham with 1 tsp wholegrain mustard and cheddar, close to our ham and cheese toastie.
- Brie and cranberry: swap the cheddar for 40g brie; see the meat-free brie and cranberry toastie for timings.
- Bubble and squeak: a 1cm layer of mashed potato and sprouts instead of stuffing; add 30 seconds.
- Nut roast: a thin slice of leftover nut roast with cranberry and vegan cheese for a vegetarian or vegan version.
Mistakes to avoid
- Overfilling a standard machine: more than about 120g total filling stops the seal. See how to stop toasties leaking.
- Wet gravy: thin, hot gravy soaks the bread and leaks. Use cold, set gravy or serve it on the side for dipping.
- Using leftovers that are too old: eat cooked turkey within about 2 days of Christmas Day, kept chilled.
- Skipping the rest: the cranberry pocket gets very hot. Wait a minute.
For more ideas, see the full toastie recipes collection, or our best toastie maker guide if you're putting one on the Christmas list.
FAQs
How do I know the centre is hot enough?
Cut it and look for steam rising from the middle, and touch-test the turkey. If it is only warm, close it back in the machine for another minute; the bread can take it.
Can I use leftover roast chicken instead of turkey?
Yes, the quantities and timings are the same. Shred it finely and use the same layering order.
Can I freeze leftovers for toasties later?
Cooked turkey and stuffing freeze well in flat portions. Defrost them fully in the fridge overnight before making the toastie, then heat until piping hot.